关于audiolab傲立功放音色的疑问

Shinji

这牌子的功放我没有听过，但是朋友给推荐过，中文媒体的普遍说法是音色不错推力也很好。勃总对8000A和8000S的评价也很高。但是我看英国what hifi对这牌子的8000S，8200A，8300A（看评测发表时间都是国产之后的货）和国外论坛网友对这牌子的功放的音色评价很糟糕。
https://www.whathifi.com/audiola ... type=review&pos=top
以上是what hifi对8000S的评测，重点是There's little richness, so if you want an easy listen, best look elsewhere,This is no rhythm machine. It fails to cohere like Roksan's Kandy does, and the 8000S also lacks authority at the lowest frequencies, sounding overly crisp in the wrong system.
https://www.whathifi.com/audiola ... type=review&pos=top
以上是what hifi对8200A的评测，重点是Sounds too clinical.needs careful system matching if forceful treble isn’t to annoy However, play something low-key such as Allison Krauss and Union Station’s Paper Airplane and there’s something missing.
It’s the kind of natural warmth and subtlety class leaders such as Roksan’s Kandy K2 have in abundance. A little more rhythmic integrity wouldn’t go amiss, either.

The 8200A is impressive, and can inform excellently, but it doesn’t stir the soul enough. Some rivals manage both.
https://www.whathifi.com/audiola ... type=review&pos=top
以上是what hifi对8300A的评测，重点是Despite all this obvious talent we’re not totally bowled over with the overall performance. Compared with alternatives from the likes of Rega and Naim, the Audiolab is a little short in its sense of rhythmic drive. The 8300A doesn’t communicate the changing momentum of a piece of music as well as we’d like.

That means the initial build-up of tension in The Dead Weather’s 60 Feet Tall isn’t particularly obvious. Similarly, the sheer energy and drive in OutKast’s Hey Ya! Is diluted, meaning a notable slice of the song’s sense of fun is lost.

It doesn’t help that the amplifier isn’t flawless in the way it communicates low-level dynamic shifts either. Nina Simone’s vocals on the haunting Strange Fruit come through with less passion than we’re used to, while the steadily growing power in Arvo Part’s Tabula Rasa doesn’t have the impact we’d expect.

The story is much the same through the phono stage. It’s a decent effort with low levels of noise and a good amount of insight, but also loses some of the solidity and authority of the line stages.
https://www.stereo.net.au/forums ... es-it-compare-with/
以上是一个澳大利亚论坛对audiolab功放的讨论，摘录如下
1、Pretty clinical and dry sounding
2、Agree with bwhitesox. Audiolab the sound is on the dry side but very good on dynamic & punchy.Very Good for Movies but a bit dry for Music.
3、Sad to say, my taste was not sophisticated enough for Audiolab; I even found the Cyrus a little dry for me  but I discovered all the above in the shop audition - there really was no need to take the Audiolab home to try, they weren't for me.
4、 Well built, rather hard sounding, but with excellent ability to cope with difficult load impedances.
5、I agree about the amps. I found them a bit lifeless and flat sounding.
6、They sound a tad thin and dry in the bass, but have a clean, sharp sound.  Sonically, they were not a good match for my VAF I-93 speakers,


综合以上的结论是audiolab功放的推力不错，声音明亮干净清脆充满细节，声场开阔。但是声音clinical（过分平淡），干、硬，没有节奏感或者说韵律感（This is no rhythm machine.）。为何what hifi和国外论坛上的评价和中文媒体和论坛上的差别这么大？难道老外的耳朵不一样？还是他们不盲目迷信所谓英国声？还有一点，这牌子网络上的文案把一系列的产品放一起，然后标上what hifi五星推荐，其实audiolab得过what hifi五星推荐的只有CD机和解码器，功放从来没有得过what hifi五星，这种文案给人感觉就是有点故意混淆视听了。

余音绕良

交易区新帖推荐

因为它早已经从英国声变成了中国广东深圳宝安区西乡镇之声了。和“美丽安之声“一样，有了之声然后就变成了猪声！

wetdays

每个人的听感都是不一样的，还有搭配，环境等都是不一样，当然结论就不一样了。

发烧有节制

确实不咋滴

shalfred

IAG先歌集团出品，制造厂在江西，哎，已经完全不是当年的英国产的傲立了。

tomer

交易区新帖推荐

以前傲立是不错的，当初还曾作为国产音响大展的参考器材，现在基本上大多数都走中性化路线了，想找回老的味道只有淘二手或DIY胆机了

Shinji

tomer 发表于 2018-7-7 15:38
以前傲立是不错的，当初还曾作为国产音响大展的参考器材，现在基本上大多数都走中性化路线了，想找回老的味 ...

问题不是中性，老外说是干，乏味，硬，有一个老外换了naim之后说和naim比audiolab是glass cutter（划玻璃刀）

狱霸

看起来很适合隔壁耳机铁匠铺人士拥有，所谓高素质啊

狱霸

韵律感不是缺乏乐感的人明白，能欣赏的，还会被他们认为是虚无的东西，只有高低频是实在的。。。其实“深圳宝安区西乡镇”出品是最适合他们欣赏的了

喜善

嘿嘿，naim，天朗，这些有音律感的器材，大多数是加了味精的，所谓调音。
平价器材里面，傲立放出来的声音才最像原声。
就像吃鸡，白切鸡才是最原味的，你喜欢吃盐焗鸡，那是你喜好，但是一定要说

SPETR

英国的几个牌子都被糟蹋了，确实可惜，特别是对于不想在器材上投入太多的烧友而言。
对于不惜代价的高烧友来说则无所谓了，上到十万元以上，自然看到的是一片新天地了。

狱霸

现实中为什么邓丽君没高没低没力的有这么多人，不止一代人听她？吃味精唱的？还是享受神秘的专属加特制味精录音了？
为什么邓丽君的歌看似容易唱，很轻松，自己去模仿却连气都喘不过来？
发烧友最好自己有点乐感会唱唱歌这样更靠谱

狱霸

“因为好听的音响系统是加了味精的所以你应该买我的难听的音响”——两个裁缝的洗脑术到今天依然管用
难吃的药能治病，难听的音响坚持听有什么益处还真想不出来，或者真能坚持听下去？

深圳仔

tomer 发表于 2018-7-7 15:38
以前傲立是不错的，当初还曾作为国产音响大展的参考器材，现在基本上大多数都走中性化路线了，想找回老的味 ...

现在许多英国功放品牌都被中国收购了，转国内生产，声音大打折扣！要买就买英国人设计英国人制作的功放，音箱，如naim   prOAC

Shinji

狱霸 发表于 2018-7-7 17:35
“因为好听的音响系统是加了味精的所以你应该买我的难听的音响”——两个裁缝的洗脑术到今天依然管用
难吃 ...

刘汉盛在音响二十要里就说了，一件冷音色的器材不能说是美的。而且就我去现场音乐会的经验，真实乐器的声音绝对不是冷的。