转一avforums编辑对LG偏光3D的评论

whindson

测试机器是LW650T,应该对应国内LW6500.总评是
编辑的下面这段话解释了为啥只给推荐:
If we'd have reviewed the LW650T prior to the LW550T there's no doubt the 650 would have been a worthy recipient of a Highly Recommended award but, as it is, it will just have to cope with 'merely' being given the Recommended badge. It can blame the 550 for representing such good value for that.
因为LW650T比LW550T贵....
下面是3d评论:
If I were being picky, and I am, the loss of resolution, when compared to the last 3D TV (Panasonic VT30) through the doors is just about perceptible, with perfect eyesight from within 4 feet. That would probably translate to around 5 and 7 feet for the 47 and 55 inch versions, respectively, but the added sense of depth increases resolution perception and I certainly don't feel I'm missing out - quite the opposite, in fact! Some object to 'scan lines' being evident in LGs Cinema 3D system but I have to say, again, I had to be very close to the screen to notice them and certainly closer than is a comfortable viewing position. The lack of crosstalk, when compared to other 3D LCDs, is also very refreshing as are the wide viewing angles. The glasses are extremely comfortable in use with less light lost than active eyewear and let's not forget they're cheap as the proverbial chips - not a factor to be sneezed at when you've children (or clumsy adults) in the equation. Viewing angles on the vertical plane aren't generous but we don't envisage many will be standing up to watch their movies.
编辑说自己是个挑剔的人,对比vt30,分辨率的丢失在4英尺(1.2m)内,要有一双很好(perfect eyesight)视力的眼睛才能看得出,47和55大概是5英尺和7英尺,但是良好的景深感确让我觉得分辨率反而提升了.扫描线还是可见,但要说明的是,我必须在很近的距离,近至甚至超过正常的观看距离才能看到.串扰以及观看视角优于其他3d液晶,亮度减少要比主动的少.垂直观看角度不够大,但没有太多人是站着看电影的吧....

cosco

景深效果偏光比快门的好很多，具有强烈的真实感。

sxdljt

用事实给说偏光不好的人一个有力的回击。有些人根本就没去

sxdljt

商场比较，就一味谩骂偏光式的不好，说这个是枪，那个是枪。

whindson

不过cnet就对偏光3d评价较低....

友山

原帖由 whindson 于 2011-7-28 14:43 发表
不过cnet就对偏光3d评价较低....

avforums对偏光3D性能给分也不是参考级的。

whindson

原帖由 友山 于 2011-7-28 14:50 发表

avforums对偏光3D性能给分也不是参考级的。

其实偏光很烂,看imax双机偏光3d,头稍微歪一点就重影了[s:18]

友山

原帖由 cosco 于 2011-7-28 14:00 发表
景深效果偏光比快门的好很多，具有强烈的真实感。

不要跟快门液晶比，跟快门等离子比比看呢。[s:14]
不管是CNET还是avforums,3D效果参照级别的只在等离子快门3D中！
VT30除了眼镜舒适度方面没能达到参照级别外，其它三项3D方面重要指标都是Reference(参照级)》》》》》》

[ 本帖最后由 友山 于 2011-7-28 20:47 编辑 ]

whindson

对比下GT30B的3D

Scores
Contrast ratio/dynamic range
Black level
Colour reproduction out of the box
Colour reproduction calibrated
Greyscale out of the box
Greyscale calibrated
ISF or calibration controls available
Video processing SD/HD
3D performance side by side
3D performance sequential
3D performance crosstalk
3D Glasses comfort/performance
Networking/DNLA/internet/audio video streaming
Features
Ease of use/menus/remote/settings
Sound quality built-in
Value for money
Overall

whindson

这个是LW650T的打分

Scores
Contrast ratio/dynamic range
Black level
Colour reproduction out of the box
Colour reproduction calibrated
Greyscale out of the box
Greyscale calibrated
ISF or calibration controls available
Video processing SD/HD
3D performance side by side
3D performance sequential
3D performance crosstalk
3D glasses comfort/performance
Sound quality built in
Networking/DNLA/internet/audio video streaming
Features
Ease of use/menus/remote/settings
Value for money
Overall

whindson

再来看看cnet的神机pnd8000在avforums的评测打分:

Scores
Contrast ratio/dynamic range
Black level
Colour reproduction out of the box
Colour reproduction calibrated
Greyscale out of the box
Greyscale calibrated
ISF or calibration controls available
Video processing SD/HD
3D performance side by side
3D performance sequential
3D performance crosstalk
3D Glasses comfort/performance
Networking/DNLA/internet/audio video streaming
Features
Ease of use/menus/remote/settings
Sound quality built-in
Value for money
Overall

3D电视机SONY和松下明显技高一筹。

shouyee

原帖由 dayornight 于 2011-7-28 18:31 发表
3D电视机SONY和松下明显技高一筹。

没错！

LG根本提不上！！！

shouyee

LG这个烂品牌，

谁买谁上当！

http://www.jd-bbs.com/thread-2712682-1-1.html

sxdljt

原帖由 shouyee 于 2011-7-28 19:33 发表
LG这个烂品牌，

谁买谁上当！

http://www.jd-bbs.com/thread-2712682-1-1.html

用了七年的冰箱坏了，造成了这么大心灵创伤？到处发贴骂LG，看来你收入不高啊。