[--评测--] 搭上08年的末班车--记SONY S550 BD-PLAYER,更新 与ps3的对比

Ep-71

原帖由 NOTHING 于 2008-12-10 13:11 发表


影音发烧,其他地方就得省钱啦~~~    偶很容易将鞋穿坏,so 只能买一般的过渡下

我跟你剛好相反 -__- '...

阿丹

交易区新帖推荐

稀饭直播～
N版请努力！
支持ing

NOTHING

The time has come to help potential buyers decide on either the S550 or the BD55. I received my S550 last week and bought the BD55 today. Now here is the comparison for both units. For the PQ comparison I used my parents 65" Sharp Aquos 1080P LCD.

Build Quality
S550 - Excellent for the price. Solid. Built in Japan.
BD55 - Not bad for the price. Very good. Built in China.
Winner - S550.

Sound Quality From HDMI Output
S550 - Very good, bass from the HDMI output is a little weak.
BD55 - The sound quality from the HDMI output sounds fuller than the S550's HDMI output. I have to choice to use its internal decoders, or bitstream the sound to use my receiver's decoders.
Winner - BD55.

Bootup Time
I had to be fair on the bootup time. I made sure that I disabled the quickstart mode on the S550. Both players bootup around 20 seconds.
Winner: Tie.

Loading Time
S550 - It just depends on the disc.
BD55 - A tad faster than the S550.
Winner - BD55

Picture Quality
S550 - Very good. Details are sharp, color is good, PQ has a natural look to it.
BD55 - Excellent. Details are sharper than the S550, color is excellent and more vibrant than the S550, PQ has a somewhat glossy look to itm but also has a natural look to it.
Winner - BD55.

Conclusion
As Panasonic continues their hertiage of producing excellent proforming blu-ray players, the BD55 is perhaps the best blu-ray player on the market for its price range and the best blu-ray player that Panasonic has made so far. Sony again can't reach Panasonic's level of expertise of blu-ray players. Sony should learn from them. Below are the pros and cons of both players.

Pros
S550
Excellent Build Quality.
Excellent Onscreen Display (Video bitrate, Video codec, audio codec, etc)
Very Good PQ.
Very Good Audio.
Decent DVD Upscaling.
Quiet Fan.
Quiet BD Drive.
Good loading times.

BD55
Very Good Build Quality.
Excellent PQ.
Good DVD Upscaling.
Excellent Audio.
Fast BD Drive.
Fast loading time.
Quiet Fan.

CONS
S550
No Frame by frame option.
Some people say that Sony uses an inferior blu-ray processing chip this year instead of using the Sigma chip which is consider better in PQ.

BD55
Does not have a detailed On-Screen display as the S550.
Frame by frame controls do not work good.

UPDATE 1: Second comparison on post #7.
UPDATE 2: Added the TV that I used for the PQ comparison.

NOTHING

The first posting was my first impressions of both players and it is not the final one. First comparisons are always a placebo effect to me. This my final comparison.

BD Picture Quality
S550 - I actully prefer the more natural pq that produces. It is not too sharp, just perfect. Colors are just right. No color push at all. I guess Sony tweaked the performance on its NEC chip.
BD50 - I'm noticing that the pq has a red push to it as a couple people noted.

Build Quality
S550 - Excellent build quality for the price.
BD55 - Vey good, but could have been better.

DVD PQ
No difference in PQ.

Sound Quality
S550 - I fixed the bass volume issue. The subwoofer volume was low on my receiver.
BD55 - No difference from before.

Conclusion
I have to retract what I said about Sony in the conclusion of the first post. Sony is as good as Panasonic in blu-ray players. The S550 is an excellent blu-ray player like the BD55. The S550 is more refined than the BD55. The price that I paid for the S550 was in the upper $200 range. The BD55 is NOT worth the extra money from the S550 and I'm going to return it (BD55) back to the store on Monday. I can put the money saved towards a new tv that I might buy next month. I'm glad that I did the second comparison.

快乐骑士

原帖由 NOTHING 于 2008-12-10 11:28 发表
但昨天真正让我开心地是：　　用了这个ｄｄ（顶天立地）　　　效果明显　用了４块啦

家里乱的一团遭～～～　　真正要感谢的是ｌｐ达人 ，[s:56] 　　　家里能搞成这样的　除了痴迷　就是要做好家庭和谐喽！

N版着重介绍一下这块搓衣板吧[s:14]

[ 本帖最后由 快乐骑士 于 2008-12-10 18:33 编辑 ]

NOTHING

交易区新帖推荐

有空你自己过来听效果，之后我用频谱仪器测试大概看下曲线。 目前效果改善很多！

w0j0s0

慢点我也要两块........[s:14] ...............回去局擦办.........[s:14]

啊土伯

有学习的感觉  顶你一下下

NOTHING

[wmv]http://cdn1-84.projectplaylist.com/e1/static10/349/1118753.mp3[/wmv]

You know I can't smile without you
I can't smile without you
I can't laugh and I can't sing
I'm finding it hard to do anything
you see I feel sad when you're sad
I feel glad when you're glad
if you only knew what I'm going through
Barry Manilow
I just can't smile without you
you came along just like a song
and brighten my day
who would of believed that you where part of a dream
now it all seems light years away
and now you know I can't smile without you
I can't smile without you
I can't laugh and I can't sing
I'm finding it hard to do anything
you see I feel sad when your sad
if you only knew what I'm going through
I just can't smile
now some people say happiness takes so very long to find
well, I'm finding it hard leaving your love behind me
and you see I can't smile without you
I can't smile without you
I can't laugh and I can't sing
I'm finding it hard to do anything
you see I feel glad when you're glad
I feel sad when you're sad
if you only knew what I'm going through
I just can't smile without you

[ 本帖最后由 NOTHING 于 2008-12-17 09:03 编辑 ]

NOTHING

测试bd如下

[ 本帖最后由 NOTHING 于 2008-12-17 09:34 编辑 ]

NOTHING

ps3  完全的优势:   1 快速的读盘  2 蓝牙遥控器  3 价格优势  4 游戏性能

sony  s550 的优势:  1 更自然\层次感\阳光感的视频   2 音频上更有质感, 细腻度更好


播放方式:  s550->ps3, ps3->s550    一张片子轮流切换

1 wall e (dts master hd)  sony的bd播放器,个人感觉是画面能力强于音频, 读盘肯定比ps3 长一些,不过不影响观看,
换上ps3后,色彩一下子变得浓郁,尤其是红色,类似反转片.....之后才明白 原来是没有切换到ps3 调整的投影机参数...呵呵  在音频部分 ps3 的音频显得更犀利,而且声压输出比s550 整整大了7个db左右

2 功夫bd(lpcm),  这张测试片 我播的最多,  bd 画面明显对比 dvd 更sharp  黑位更好, 音频改变较大 尤其是低频, 细节更爆棚!  不过在使用2930的时候 dvd 的功夫 音效\画面我也可以接受

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------热身结束

3 变形金刚(dd ture hd)~~~越来越爆棚的音效 可见软件才是根本,如果一部片子制作就有问题,那你的系统再高级也不会发挥威力
大概打分
s 550 视频 7  音频 6.5     
ps3  视频  5 音频  5

4 换成演唱会,不是近场录音  这张bd 我认为是制作挺烂的,画面一般 音频也一般  menu更烂~~~对比蔡琴的bd
我认为它不合格
大概打分
s 550 视频 7  音频 6.5     
ps3  视频  5 音频  5

5 300勇士(dd ture hd), 考究黑位的片子 独特的filming感
s 550 视频 6  音频 7     
ps3  视频  5 音频  5

ps3 更game化,  追求强烈的刺激感\浓郁的对比度  价格是它的优势

s550 在付出比ps3 高一些的代价后,能得到更好的视频\以及音频,

如果你不在乎"源码"显示,而且又有资金预算限制,ps3 能够接受,它还能继续"混"下去.

但如果你是名严谨的影音爱好者,愿意为10-20%的提升效果付出代价的话, s550 是个不错的bdplayer入门选择

记得上次看过的05fd,明显的 它的视频更好,但又要多花去1xxx的代价,唉~~~ 还有更好的denon3800  lx91,期待他们的降价


另: 分数起点不高,是因为考虑到 还位测试中级的bdplayer  例如:  sony 5000es\lx71a\denon 2500bt

偶得ps3 当然也不会出, 退役之后 它会去卧室,打打游戏啥的

[ 本帖最后由 NOTHING 于 2008-12-17 09:38 编辑 ]

ae900

ps3 的优势还有播放移动硬盘的bd,播bd-r.rbd.

w0j0s0

没有冷门.....不好看........

NOTHING

原帖由 w0j0s0 于 2008-12-17 10:18 发表
没有冷门.....不好看........

冷门? sony 自己的东西  player 比不过 ps3  , 它可以买块豆腐撞死算了

小哥

原帖由 NOTHING 于 2008-12-17 10:31 发表


冷门? sony 自己的东西  player 比不过 ps3  , 它可以买块豆腐撞死算了

应该是这样的。