英国DVD Times对索尼V2000的评测再次证实家电网友Svideo是个骗子！

bigbrother

针对目前家电论坛网友Svideo对索尼Bravia产品进行的一系列无端攻击，尤其是谎称索尼V系列存在“去隔行效果很差”，从本人的40V300A使用情况看是没有这种情况的，所以进行了一点调查，下面是结果：

英国DVD Times在06年6月15日发表了对索尼32V2000（国内型号32V200A）液晶电视的详细评测，其中一项就是去隔行效果的评测，网址如下：

http://www.dvdtimes.co.uk/content.php?contentid=61818

节选英文原文：
Deinterlacer Torture TestSimply put, the deinterlacer is that part of the TV that fakes progressive scan pictures out of non-progressive scan (interlaced) ones. Interlaced video is what you typically get from any video device that isn't connected via Component video or HDMI, as well as from analogue and digital TV broadcasts. The 1080i HDTV format is also interlaced. Although interlaced video - which works by drawing half-frames rather than whole ones, to save bandwidth - is native to most of the old CRT TVs on the market, LCD panels are progressive. That means that the Deinterlacer in the TV needs to convert any interlaced video into Progressive to turn what would otherwise display as a mess of jagged patterns into a natural, visible picture with full motion fluidity.

My favourite test for any TV's deinterlacer is to play a fast (60 frames per second) video game in interlaced mode. My weapon of choice today was Sonic Adventure DX on the American NTSC Nintendo GameCube. After playing through the first half of the first level, I was satisfied that the deinterlacer in the TV is up to par. （在玩完第一关后，我对该电视的去隔行水平很满意） Only once on a very fast moving sequence did it let through some combing artefacts. There also weren't too many jagged diagonal lines. In short, the deinterlacing is exactly what I expected from a high quality consumer TV. （简单的说，其去隔行效果正是我对一款高品质电视所期待的一样）

The deinterlacing circuitry was also adept at recreating the original FILM frames from 24 and 25fps movie sources (because Film material needs to be treated differently to Video camera material in order to avoid jaggies). The old LCD WEGA from 2004 that I've been used to featured astonishingly good 3:2 Pulldown Detection which meant that it did a good job of showing interlaced NTSC movies (for example, NTSC DVDs played from an older, Interlaced only player, or NTSC Laser Discs). The improvement is even greater on this new BRAVIA - NTSC DVDs look incredible played from an Interlaced player, with almost no jagged patterns whatsoever. （新款Bravia的提高更明显（相对于笔者的WEGA），NTSC制式的DVD在隔行扫描DVD影碟机播放出的效果非常色，几乎没有锯齿的出现）

New however, is 2:2 Pulldown Detection, which simply means that now the same great Interlaced Film handling is present for PAL movies too! My old LCD WEGA treated PAL movies in the same way it would treat Video material. This meant that on downward camera pans, you could see jagged lines on diagonal parts of the picture. Things are much smoother now, so no longer will you have to put up with (too many) jaggies when a good film comes on TV. The PAL pulldown detection isn't quite as good as the NTSC, so I do recommend that you use a Progressive Scan DVD player that handles the pulldown for you, rather than leaving it up to the TV.

It's also nice to add that the slight flickering colours from the old WEGA models is now gone. On RGB SCART pictures (which I used to use for hooking up my old Freeview box) from the old 2004 TV, looking up close would show that colours would have a light flicker to them - most noticeable on the red SKY NEWS logo. The colours are completely stable on the KDL-32V2000. （在看普通节目时，老款WEGA出现的色彩闪烁现象在32V2000上完全没有）


在这里希望大家睁大眼睛，网上骗子多，不要被某自称专家的谎言所骗

祝大家购机愉快！:victory:

myworld

不是同一型号，没法比。

bigbrother

原帖由 myworld 于 2007-7-24 18:50 发表
不是同一型号，没法比。

型号名不一样，实际配置性能指标都一样

svideo

真理越辨越明，这个问题愿意奉陪到底。
给您提供几个考查索尼去隔行效果的方法：
索尼40V200A或X200A，皇家赌场演示碟，索尼自己制作的，有白色立柱的那个镜头，画面移动时，百叶窗效应明显。
索尼40V300A，索尼的橄榄球比赛的那个演示碟，有个镜头是穿白色运动服的运动员突然起跑，白色运动服上可以明显看出交错的锯齿。
这些现象都是比较容易观察到的。
而且索尼的去隔行效果不好，比东芝的37WL67C严重，当然东芝37WL67C也不是做的很好。但是68C就好多了。大家可以自己比较。

stwhirp

楼住是SB,鉴定完毕~

bigbrother

原帖由 svideo 于 2007-7-24 18:54 发表
真理越辨越明，这个问题愿意奉陪到底。
给您提供几个考查索尼去隔行效果的方法：
索尼40V200A或X200A，皇家赌场演示碟，索尼自己制作的，有白色立柱的那个镜头，画面移动时，百叶窗效应明显。
索尼40V300A， ...

索尼和东芝用着不同的演示，结果你看出来索尼的去隔行效果不好........

原来你的“评测”就是这么去商场评出来的[s:18]

bigbrother

原帖由 stwhirp 于 2007-7-24 18:59 发表
楼住是SB,鉴定完毕~

你是马甲，鉴定完毕

kuroko

看大家这么吵闹 倒是对索尼的46X200A开始感兴趣了

bigbrother

原帖由 tt4 于 2007-7-24 19:13 发表
哪国都有枪手，英国人不见得就是干净的，而且从历史看，英国人最不可靠
倒是想知道楼主拿了索尼多少钱办事？？？

我没拿索尼的钱，索尼倒是拿了我不少钱[s:14]

这个帖子是在揭露骗子真面目

killers

楼主的心理其实可以理解，自己买的东西被贬低的一无是处肯定心里不好受，争一争至少能起到点掩耳盗铃的作用

bigbrother

原帖由 killers 于 2007-7-24 19:29 发表
楼主的心理其实可以理解，自己买的东西被贬低的一无是处肯定心里不好受，争一争至少能起到点掩耳盗铃的作用

忌妒心[s:38]

ncwangw

原帖由 stwhirp 于 2007-7-24 18:59 发表
楼住是SB,鉴定完毕~

[s:97] 你是马甲，一共只发一贴，还是这一句，鉴定完毕~

ncwangw

原帖由 killers 于 2007-7-24 19:29 发表
楼主的心理其实可以理解，自己买的东西被贬低的一无是处肯定心里不好受，争一争至少能起到点掩耳盗铃的作用

[s:18] 好的不学，学svideo乱用成语，可悲

killers

呵呵，或者是说驼鸟心理。

标准心理不成熟的表现。40V300A似乎也没有什么让人嫉妒的地方，当然也许在某些鼠目寸光的人看来已经足够让别人眼馋了:victory: 呵呵，或者说是井底之蛙[s:14]

   不懂成语可以回去补习小学语文，无知不要紧，无知还出来现眼就不对了[s:14]

killers

原帖由 bigbrother 于 2007-7-24 19:33 发表


忌妒心

这位真有意思，回贴后还在文字后面留下表明自己真实身份的签名[s:14] [s:14] [s:14] [s:14] [s:14] [s:14] [s:14]

[ 本帖最后由 killers 于 2007-7-24 19:53 编辑 ]