转一某国外网站的总评表，某些人不是说等离子得高分的一打吗，看图吧

whindson

某些人不是说等离子得高分的一打吗，看图吧
还是一句话：等离子没那么神～，别整天xx的先天优势，就看厂商怎么做。如果说pdp的那个什么先天优势真那么好，那也不会在专业领域中那么不济了（专业领域的东西都不便宜，成本也都不低，等离子不是不能做小，这和当初液晶只有6bit说液晶做到10bit不可能一样，只要有人去做，10多年技术积累下来要做小还真不是什么不可能的事情，但为什么那些专业领域的厂家都不做呢？）。好产品各阵营都有，等离子和液晶，只要厂商下功夫，都能做出画质好的产品。


[ 本帖最后由 whindson 于 2011-5-2 00:39 编辑 ]

圣熊

拿评测网站来互压是没有意义的.......

whindson

另外转下cnet的
Best HDTVs overall

• [url=]Print[/url]
• [url=]E-mail[/url]
• [url=]Share[/url]

    (Updated April 27, 2011 6:11 AM PDT)
     David Katzmaier
Senior editor


   We review a lot of high-definition televisions here at CNET, but the list below represents only the best. It collects our current highest-recommended televisions arranged in order of overall score, regardless of TV type, technology, brand, or size. These cumulative ratings indicate which HDTVs scored highest considering major areas we rate: design, features, and performance. We don't expect this list to cover it for everyone, however, so we've also created supplemental lists broken down by technology type and screen size. Choose from the lists to the left according to which criteria matter most to you.  

     Panasonic TC-PVT20/25 series   With both 2D and 3D sources, Panasonic's flagship TC-PVT20/25 series plasma TV delivers outstanding overall picture quality.
Price: $2,849.00 (check prices)

• 4.0 stars Excellent
    
  Overall        score: 8.7 (4.0 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       Samsung PNC8000 series  Samsung's PNC8000 series plasma TV produces one of the highest-quality pictures we've tested this year in both 2D and 3D modes, yet costs less than its direct competition.
Price: $1,897.00 - $2,299.99 (check prices)

• 4.0 stars Excellent
    
  Overall        score: 8.3 (4.0 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
        Samsung UND8000 series  The Samsung UND8000 TV delivers best-in-class looks and features, but its picture quality--thanks to uneven screen uniformity--is ultimately not as good as that of many less expensive models.
Price: $2,699.00 - $3,239.99 (check prices)

• 4.0 stars Excellent
    
  Overall        score: 8.1 (4.0 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       Panasonic TC-PGT30 series  Excellent all-around picture quality combined with improved features and styling should make the Panasonic TC-PGT30 TV a favorite among bigger-spending plasma seekers.
Price: $1,484.40 - $1,978.00 (check prices)

• 4.0 stars Excellent
    
  Overall        score: 8.0 (4.0 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       Vizio XVT3SV series   The Vizio XVT3SV series' excellent picture quality, thoughtful design, scads of features, and reasonable price combine to make it the best value among high-end LED-based LCD TVs today.
Price: $1,299.99 - $1,899.99 (check prices)

• 4.0 stars Excellent
    
  Overall        score: 8.0 (4.0 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       LG LX9500 series  Loads of features, a nearly frameless design, and excellent overall 2D performance increase the appeal of the LG LX9500 series LED-based LCD TV, but its 3D picture needs work.
Price: $2,799.99 - $3,399.99 (check prices)

• 4.0 stars Excellent
    
  Overall        score: 8.0 (4.0 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       Samsung PNC7000 series  Among the better 2D performers available, the Samsung PNC7000 series plasma also delivers 3D for less than the competition.
Price: $1,597.00 - $1,999.99 (check prices)

• 4.0 stars Excellent
    
  Overall        score: 8.0 (4.0 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       LG LE8500 series  With the excellent picture quality of the local-dimming LE8500, LG challenges other LCD makers for videophile appeal.
Price: $1,499.99 - $1,998.98 (check prices)

• 4.0 stars Excellent
    
  Overall        score: 8.0 (4.0 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       Samsung UND6400 series  Solid overall 2D and 3D picture quality, as well as a wealth of features and beautiful looks, mark the Samsung UND6400 as one of the better edge-lit LED-based LCD TVs we've tested.
Price: $1,221.76 - $1,599.99 (check prices)

• 3.5 stars Very good
    
  Overall        score: 7.9 (3.5 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       Sony XBR-HX909 series  Although its black levels challenge the best ever, some other picture-related aspects of the Sony XBR-HX909 series don't live up to the high price.
Price: $1,999.00 - $3,599.99 (check prices)

• 3.5 stars Very good
    
  Overall        score: 7.9 (3.5 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       Panasonic TC-PGT25 series  Although it does deliver excellent 2D picture quality, the 3D-compatible Panasonic TC-PGT25 series can't match the overall performance of the competition's best plasmas.
Price: $1,199.88 - $2,099.99 (check prices)

• 3.5 stars Very good
    
  Overall        score: 7.7 (3.5 stars)
  
  

Read full review
  [url=]Close[/url]  
  
       Samsung UNC8000 series  Its 3D is still a work in progress and its 2D picture quality comes up short of the best available, but the high-end Samsung UNC8000 series still offers superb features, solid performance, and unique style.
Price: $2,349.00 - $2,797.00 (check prices)

• 3.5 stars Very good
    
  Overall        score: 7.6 (3.5 stars)
  
  

Read full review

whindson

原帖由 圣熊 于 2011-5-1 23:49 发表
拿评测网站来互压是没有意义的.......

只是看不习惯某些等疯的一些言论而已。
某些人不是说等离子得高分的一抓一大把，液晶得高分的没多少嘛。不说这两个网站多权威，至少这两网站的评测比国内要好得多
flat的2010年强烈推荐的等离子：液晶是4：3
cnet的bets hdtv overall等离子:液晶是5：7

[ 本帖最后由 whindson 于 2011-5-2 00:00 编辑 ]

圣熊

D8000的综合得分是高，不过那是靠设计和功能拉上来的，画质得分还不如低2级的D6400（3D画质除外）...........

whindson

原帖由 圣熊 于 2011-5-1 23:57 发表
D8000的综合得分是高，不过那是靠设计和功能拉上来的，画质得分还不如低2级的D6400（3D画质除外）...........

这贴没说道画质。
就算单比cnet的picture，得分相同的等离子也未必比液晶多
只是揭一些人所谓的总评而已
给某些人看点事实：cnet 43－49寸best hdtv中等离子连个影子都没有。。。。

whindson

cnet的editor choice的桂冠在HDTV中是给vt25系列和vizio xvt3sv系列的。